Melanie at craigscottcapital is a search phrase with no confirmed person behind it. The FINRA and SEC records reviewed for this guide do not name a registered representative, principal, or officer called Melanie at the firm. This guide shows what the public record does confirm about Craig Scott Capital LLC. It also gives you a repeatable method to verify any financial professional before you share money or data.
Quick answers
- Is Melanie CraigScottCapital a verified person? No primary regulatory record confirms her identity or role.
- Is Craig Scott Capital LLC still in business? No. FINRA expelled the firm, and the expulsion became final on September 7, 2017.
- Why did FINRA expel it? The default decision cited excessive trading, churning, and false statements to FINRA.
- What is the firm’s CRD number? 155924.
Who Is Melanie CraigScottCapital?
Melanie CraigScottCapital is a search term, not a verified profile. No FINRA BrokerCheck or SEC record reviewed for this guide lists a Melanie as an employee, principal, or registered representative of Craig Scott Capital LLC. Some online pages attach names such as Melanie Craig or Melanie Dandell to the firm. The primary records do not support those links.
Is Melanie CraigScottCapital a Real Person?
A person named Melanie may exist. She may even have worked for the firm in a non-registered role. BrokerCheck lists registered brokers only. Administrative staff, marketers, and writers never appear there.
Absence from BrokerCheck does not prove she never worked there. It means no public regulator data can confirm it. Treat any claim about her as unverified until you see a primary source.
Melanie Craig Biography and Professional Profile
No verified Melanie Craig biography exists in FINRA, SEC, or state regulator data. Be cautious with any page that offers a detailed career story for her. A real biography needs a named source such as a license record, an employer statement, or a court filing.
The name itself creates confusion. FINRA records list the firm’s CEO as Craig Scott Taddonio. The words Craig and Scott appear in both a person’s name and a company name. That overlap makes searches for “Melanie Craig” unreliable.
What Was Melanie’s Role at CraigScottCapital?
No public record confirms any Melanie role at CraigScottCapital. Registered representatives and principals appear in the Central Registration Depository (CRD). Roles outside that system, such as assistants or content staff, leave no regulatory trace. You cannot confirm a title without a primary source.
Melanie CraigScottCapital as an Author, Writer, or Analyst
Some pages describe Melanie as a financial writer, finance analyst, or content contributor. No primary source supports those titles. Here is how to test any such claim:
- Search BrokerCheck for her name. A registered representative holds a securities license, such as the Series 7.
- Search the SEC IAPD for investment adviser records.
- Look for a byline on a verifiable publication.
- Ask the source page to name its evidence.
If none of these steps return a match, mark the claim as unverified.
What Is Craig Scott Capital?
Craig Scott Capital LLC was a broker-dealer based in Uniondale, New York. The firm joined FINRA in January 2012. SEC filings list its business address as 1225 RXR Plaza, East Tower, in Uniondale. Its CRD number is 155924.
Craig Scott Capital Company History
The CraigScottCapital history spans about four years of active business and two more of regulatory action. This timeline comes from FINRA and SEC documents:
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| January 2012 | The firm becomes a FINRA member |
| January 2012 to December 2014 | Period of excessive trading in 11 customer accounts, per FINRA |
| October 2015 | FINRA suspends the firm for unpaid arbitration fees |
| December 2015 | The firm files Form BDW to withdraw its registration |
| January 2016 | FINRA cancels membership for unpaid fees |
| April 12, 2016 | SEC settles Regulation S-P and books-and-records charges |
| August 10, 2017 | FINRA hearing officer issues the default decision |
| September 7, 2017 | The expulsion becomes final |
Was Craig Scott Capital a Broker-Dealer?
Yes. A broker-dealer buys and sells securities for customers and sometimes for its own account. Federal law requires registration with the SEC and membership in FINRA. Craig Scott Capital held both until its registration period ended.
A broker-dealer differs from an investment adviser. Brokers earn commissions on trades. Advisers give ongoing advice and owe a fiduciary duty to clients. The two types sit in different databases, which matters for verification.
Craig Scott Capital Regulatory History
The firm faced actions from two regulators. FINRA pursued sales practice violations. The SEC pursued customer-information protection and record-keeping failures. Together, these actions produced the public regulatory milestones in the timeline above, from October 2015 to September 2017.
FINRA and Craig Scott Capital
FINRA is the self-regulatory organization that oversees U.S. broker-dealers. It first suspended the firm in October 2015 for unpaid arbitration fees. It cancelled membership in January 2016. The enforcement case continued anyway.
FINRA kept jurisdiction because its by-laws allow a complaint within two years after a cancelled membership. The conduct happened while the firm was a member.
Why Was Craig Scott Capital Expelled From FINRA?
FINRA expelled the firm for three reasons. The hearing officer found excessive trading, churning, and false statements to FINRA. The firm never answered the complaint, so FINRA entered a default decision on August 10, 2017. The firm was out of business, so FINRA imposed no fine.
Case study: How excessive trading became churning
FINRA found that three registered representatives excessively traded the accounts of 11 customers between January 2012 and December 2014. The decision used four measures:
- Turnover rate: how often the account’s holdings were bought and sold.
- Cost-to-equity ratio: how much the customer paid in costs relative to account value.
- Commissions, markups, and markdowns: the charges the customer paid.
- Control: whether the representative made the real trading decisions.
Excessive trading becomes churning when the representative acts with intent to defraud or reckless disregard for the customer. The hearing officer found that element present.
FINRA also found a supervisory system failure. The principals saw red flags and did not respond. The firm’s written supervisory procedures were deficient. FINRA found telemarketing violations too. During May to July 2014, the sales force made 1,330 calls to 1,038 numbers on do-not-call lists.
The firm also denied using recording devices when FINRA asked. The panel found the firm bought at least 50 recording devices for about $4,300. That false statement triggered a separate expulsion basis.
What you can learn: Watch for frequent trading you did not request. Compare your statements against your goals. Ask what you paid in total costs each quarter.
SEC and Regulation S-P Issues
The SEC settled a separate case on April 12, 2016. It charged the firm and its two principals, Craig S. Taddonio and Brent M. Porges. The order covered Regulation S-P violations and books-and-records failures.
What Is Regulation S-P?
Regulation S-P is the SEC rule that requires broker-dealers to protect customer records and information. Its Safeguards Rule requires written policies that keep customer information secure and confidential. The rule covers account numbers, identity documents, and financial details.
What Were the Data-Security Problems?
The SEC found that the firm used personal email addresses to receive thousands of customer faxes. One law firm summary counts more than 4,000 faxes. They contained account numbers, driver’s licenses, and passports.
The SEC also found the firm did not preserve those faxes or emails, which broke the books and records rules. Its written supervisory procedures did not match real firm practice.
The firm agreed to pay a $100,000 civil money penalty. Taddonio and Porges each agreed to pay $25,000. All three accepted the settlement without admitting or denying the findings. The order included cease-and-desist proceedings and a censure.
Case study: A cybersecurity lesson from a small broker-dealer
Law firm analysts cited this case to show that regulators expect policies to reflect real operations. A generic policy copied from a template did not satisfy the rule.
What you can learn: Ask any firm how it stores your documents. Never email passport or account details to a personal email address. Send them through a secure portal.
What Happened to CraigScottCapital?
The firm stopped operating in late 2015, lost FINRA membership in January 2016, and faced expulsion in 2017.
When Did Craig Scott Capital Close?
The firm filed Form BDW in December 2015 to withdraw its registration. FINRA cancelled its membership in January 2016. The hearing officer described the firm as out of business in 2017.
Is CraigScottCapital Still in Business?
No. The firm has no FINRA membership and cannot operate as a FINRA broker-dealer. Be careful with any site that claims to be CraigScottCapital today. Scammers sometimes reuse the names of defunct firms to look established.
Craig Scott Capital CRD and Registration Records
The Central Registration Depository (CRD) is FINRA’s database of firms and brokers. Each firm and each broker receives a unique number. Craig Scott Capital’s CRD number is 155924.
A CRD record shows:
- Registration dates and status.
- Employment history for individuals.
- Regulatory disclosures, including regulatory actions.
- Arbitration disclosures and customer complaints.
BrokerCheck displays the public part of this data.
FINRA BrokerCheck and Craig Scott Capital
FINRA BrokerCheck is a free search tool. Search by firm name or CRD number. The firm’s report discloses the expulsion. Individual reports list prior employers, including Craig Scott Capital with its CRD number and Uniondale location.
BrokerCheck reports show employment history, qualifications, disciplinary actions, civil judgments, and arbitration awards. Read the disclosure section first.
SEC Records and Craig Scott Capital
The SEC publishes enforcement orders and litigation releases. The April 2016 settled order names the firm and both principals. You can also find broker-dealer filings on the SEC’s EDGAR system.
SEC IAPD and Broker-Dealer Records Are Different
The SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) site covers investment advisers. Broker-dealers appear in BrokerCheck and in SEC filings.
| Database | Covers | Best use |
|---|---|---|
| FINRA BrokerCheck | Brokers and broker-dealers | Disciplinary history, licenses |
| SEC IAPD | Investment advisers | Form ADV, adviser disclosures |
| SEC EDGAR | Public filings and orders | Enforcement orders |
| State securities regulator | State-registered firms | Local licenses and complaints |
Search more than one database. A person can hold both a broker and an adviser registration.
Melanie CraigScottCapital: What Can Actually Be Verified?
The record confirms the firm. It does not confirm Melanie.
| Claim | Status |
|---|---|
| Craig Scott Capital LLC was a Uniondale broker-dealer with CRD 155924 | Verified |
| FINRA expelled the firm, final September 7, 2017 | Verified |
| The SEC fined the firm $100,000 and each principal $25,000 | Verified |
| Melanie worked at the firm | Not verified |
| Melanie’s title, such as analyst or writer | Not verified |
| Melanie Craig biography | Not verified |
| Melanie Dandell link to the firm | Not verified |
Why Is “Melanie From CraigScottCapital” Appearing as a Search Term?
Search engines suggest phrases based on what people type. A suggestion does not prove a person exists. People may type this phrase after seeing an email signature, a cold message, or a low-quality web page.
Search Association vs. Verified Identity
Content echoing explains much of this pattern. One page makes an unsupported claim. Other pages copy it with small changes. Search engines then see many pages and treat the claim as common. Repetition looks like proof, but it is not.
To separate the two, ask three questions:
- Does the page cite a regulator or court record?
- Can you open that record yourself?
- Does the record name the person and the role?
If any answer is no, treat the claim as an unverified online claim.
Melanie CraigScottCapital Online Presence
Online profiles prove little. Anyone can create a profile in minutes. Check these signals before you trust a name:
- Account age: New accounts with few connections deserve doubt.
- Email domain: A free email address from a financial firm is a warning sign.
- Employment history: Look for dates that match records.
- Contact requests: Be wary of anyone who moves you to private messaging quickly.
Do not share identity documents or account details with an unverified contact.
How to Verify a Financial Professional or Investment Firm
Use primary-source verification. That means you confirm facts directly with the regulator, not through a third-party page. Follow these four steps.
Check FINRA BrokerCheck
- Go to brokercheck.finra.org.
- Search the person’s name or the firm’s CRD number.
- Confirm the current registration status.
- Read the employment history and every disclosure.
You can check broker registration here in under five minutes.
Check SEC Investment Adviser Records
- Open the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site.
- Search by name or firm.
- Download the Form ADV.
- Read the disciplinary history section.
Verify Professional Credentials
Credentials such as CFP and CFA come from issuing bodies. Each body runs a public lookup. Match the name, the credential, and the status. A person who lists a credential but does not appear in the lookup has not verified it.
Check the Firm’s Legal Identity
- Confirm the firm’s registered name and address with your state securities regulator.
- Match the name on any contract to the name in the regulator record.
- Check the website’s age and ownership data.
- Call the firm’s phone number listed in the regulator database, not the one in a message.
Read More:Arts Thunderonthegulf Crafts: Gulf Coast Trip Guide
Investor Safety and Due Diligence
Investor due diligence protects you before you lose money. Apply these rules every time:
- Verify the firm and the person before you send funds.
- Reject guaranteed returns. No legitimate investment can guarantee profit.
- Treat unsolicited investment proposals with caution.
- Refuse cryptocurrency transfer requests from anyone you met online.
- Avoid pressure to act today.
- Keep copies of every statement and confirmation.
- Review each account statement for trades you did not expect.
FINRA also publishes guidance on phishing and investment group imposter scams. Report suspected fraud to FINRA, the SEC, and your state securities regulator.
CraigScottCapital Regulatory Terms Explained
| Term | Plain meaning |
|---|---|
| Broker-dealer | A firm that trades securities for customers |
| FINRA expulsion | Removal of a firm from FINRA membership |
| Default decision | A ruling issued when a respondent does not answer a complaint |
| Excessive trading | Trading too often for the customer’s goals |
| Churning | Excessive trading with intent or reckless disregard |
| Regulation S-P | SEC rule on protecting customer information |
| Books and records rule | Requirement to keep business communications |
| Written supervisory procedures | A firm’s documented oversight rules |
| Civil money penalty | A fine imposed by a regulator |
| Cease-and-desist | An order to stop a violation |
| CRD | FINRA’s registration database |
| Settled proceedings | A case resolved by agreement |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Melanie at CraigScottCapital?
No primary record identifies a Melanie at Craig Scott Capital LLC. FINRA and SEC documents name the firm, its principals, and its violations. They do not name her. Treat any biography or job title for her as unverified.
Was Craig Scott Capital legitimate?
It was a registered broker-dealer from 2012 until its membership ended. It then faced SEC and FINRA actions. FINRA expelled it in 2017 for excessive trading, churning, and false statements. The SEC fined it $100,000.
Why did FINRA expel Craig Scott Capital?
A hearing officer found three violations. The firm excessively traded and churned customer accounts, and it gave FINRA false information. or The firm also failed to supervise its representatives. The firm did not respond to the complaint, so FINRA issued a default decision.
Is Craig Scott Capital still operating?
No. It filed Form BDW in December 2015. FINRA cancelled its membership in January 2016 and expelled it in 2017. The firm cannot operate as a FINRA broker-dealer.
How do I check if a broker is registered?
Search FINRA BrokerCheck by name or CRD number. Confirm the status and read every disclosure. For advisers, also search the SEC’s IAPD. Check your state securities regulator for local registrations.
What is Regulation S-P?
Regulation S-P is an SEC rule that requires broker-dealers to protect customer records. Firms must adopt written policies that keep customer information secure. The SEC cited Craig Scott Capital under this rule in April 2016.
Can I recover money from a closed brokerage?
Sometimes. You can file a FINRA arbitration claim or contact an investor protection attorney. Deadlines apply. Collect your statements first. Ask whether the firm still has assets or insurance coverage.
Sources
- FINRA Office of Hearing Officers, Default Decision, Department of Enforcement v. Craig Scott Capital, LLC (August 10, 2017): finra.org
- SEC, Administrative Proceedings Summary, April 12, 2016: sec.gov/file/administrative-summary-64
- FINRA National Adjudicatory Council decision referencing the April 12, 2016 SEC order: finra.org
- Akin Gump, SEC enforcement action against a broker-dealer for weak cybersecurity controls (April 21, 2016)
- Dechert LLP, OnPoint on tailored cybersecurity programs (June 2016)
- FINRA BrokerCheck reports referencing CRD 155924
- SEC EDGAR filing index for Craig Scott Capital, LLC
